earth

Culture: The Human Mirror

Anthropology 110-001 | American University | Spring 2003

Tue/Fri 12:45-2:00pm | Location: MCK 108

Instructor: Josh Snodgrass

phone: (202) 885-1830 (Anthropology Department)
e-mail: j-snodgrass@northwestern.edu

bull


Class Location & Time:

Instructor Office Hours & Location:

Teaching Assistant:


Announcements:

Course Summary

This course provides an overview of the field of anthropology, which is generally divided into four subfields: 1) cultural or social anthropology, the comparative study of human societies and cultures; 2) archaeology, the study of historic and prehistoric human societies through material remains; 3) biological anthropology, the study of human evolution and biological adaptations of living people; and 4) anthropological linguistics, the study of language systems within a cultural framework.  Culture, often defined as the non-biological transmission of knowledge, values, and beliefs, has historically been a major focus of the discipline of anthropology and is the subject of this course.  This course traces changes in human culture over the past 2.5 million years, from early hominids to the development of agriculture and cities to contemporary societies and the diversity found in the world today.  Anthropology’s holistic approach provides important insights into contemporary cultural diversity and cultural change through time, two themes of this course.

General Education Information

Culture: The Human Mirror is a foundation course in Curricular Area 3, the International and Intercultural Experience, in the university’s General Education Program.  This course is the first of a two-course sequence.  Students who successfully complete this course may complete the sequence by taking one of the following second-level courses in Area 3:

        Sex, Gender, and Culture (ANTH-215)
        India: Its Living Traditions (ANTH-230)
        Human Geography: Peoples, Places, and Cultures (SIS-210)
        Confronting Our Differences/Discovering Our Similarities (SIS-220)
        The World of Islam (SIS-245)
        Latin America: History, Art, Literature (LFS-210)
        Asian and African Religious Traditions (RELG-210)
        Education for International Development (SOCY-285)


Books (Required)

Kottak, C. 2001. Anthropology: The Exploration of Human Diversity (9th Edition). McGraw-Hill.

Podolefsky, A. and Brown, P. 1999. Applying Anthropology: An Introductory Reader (7th Edition). McGraw-Hill.

Course Requirements

Your grade in the course will reflect performance on three exams, three short reaction papers, and your attendance and participation.  Exams will include objective (multiple choice & matching), fill-in-the-blank, short answer, and short essay sections.  Exams will be based on lectures, readings from the textbooks, class discussions, and videos.  The final exam will be comprehensive, yet will focus primarily on the material from the last part of the course.  Material on the exams may be different than that presented in the books, and may only be covered during course lecture and discussion.  Therefore, you are advised to arrange to get course notes from the instructor if you miss a class.  Make-up exams will only be given with official university excuses (generally medical) and must be approved by the instructor.

During the semester, you will write on your choice of three topics (based on five possibilities—see “Special Topics” on the schedule) in the form of short (two page) reaction papers.  For each of these response papers, you will write on a specific topic and discuss the ideas based on your own reaction to the topic, as well as course readings and class discussions.  Each reaction paper is due one week after it is discussed in class (e.g., if you write on race your reaction paper will be due on March 11)
.

Grading

Exam 1 -- 20%
Exam 2 -- 20%
Exam 3 -- 20%
Reaction Papers (3) -- 20%
Attendance & Participation -- 20%

Standards of Performance Evaluation:

A    Superior: demonstration of superior work in oral contributions and writing; all assignments turned in on time

B    Very Good: solid work evidenced by careful synthesis of reading, timely contributions to class discussion, and clear, logical writing; all or most assignments turned in on time

C    Satisfactory: work demonstrates some understanding of the materials and an average performance on written assignments and class discussion; some assignments turned in on time

D    Inconsistent: weak performance on all assignments and class discussion; late in turning in written work (or work is not completed); failure to meet minimum attendance requirements

F    Failing: failure to meet minimum course goals in written assignments, class participation, and other course requirements

Academic Integrity Code:

The Academic Integrity Code defines procedures and penalties for such serious infractions as plagiarism, cheating, and/or falsified data or documentation.  The instructor anticipates that students will adhere to American University's Academic Integrity Code.  Students should familiarize themselves with their responsibilities.  You may obtain copies of the Academic Integrity Code from the General Education Office or from the instructor.

Exam Dates

February 28 -- Exam 1
April 4 -- Exam 2
May 2 -- Exam
3

Schedule

Week
Dates
Lecture Topic for the Week
Reading Assignment for the Week
1
Jan. 14
Jan. 17
Course introduction; Introduction to anthropology; Four-field approach; Ethnography; Anthropological fieldwork
Film: Franz Boas: The Shackles of Tradition

K: Chapters 1 & 2
2
Jan. 21
Jan. 24
Culture; Do humans alone have culture? Cultural Diversity


K: Chapter 11; P&B: Chapters 19 (Miner) & 24 (Bohannan)
3
Jan. 28
Jan. 31
Early human evolution; Where did we come from?; Primates; Fossil evidence for early hominids
Film: Among the Wild Chimpanzees

Special Topic: Biology & Behavior—T-Shirt Smelling College Students

K: Chapters 3 & 4
4
Feb. 4
Feb. 7
Origins of material culture; Culture origins?; Early archaeological sites; Early social organization; Subsistence; Out of Africa; Human occupation of the planet

February 7--Class cancelled because of snow

K: Chapter 6; P&B: Chapter 15 (Diamond—Easter’s End)
5
Feb. 11
Feb. 14
Art and symbolic though; “The human revolution”; Language
Film: In Search of Human Origins

K: Chapters 7 & 13
6
Feb. 18
Feb. 21
February 18--Class cancelled because of snow

Origins of agriculture and domestication; New social and economic systems; Inequality; Health

Special Topic: Agriculture and Domestication—Mistakes That Keep on Giving?


K: Chapter 9; P&B: Chapter 11 (Diamond—Worst Mistake of the Human Race) & Chapter 13 (Goodman & Armelagos)
7
Feb. 25
Feb. 28
Finish section on origin of modern humans, "the human revolution", art and symbolic thought, and language

Exam 1 – Friday, February 28

Exam 1 Guidelines


8
Mar. 4
Mar. 7
Origins of complex societies; First states; Early societies of the Old World & New World; First cities

Film: Mesopotamia: Return to Eden

K: Chapter 10


9
Mar. 11
Mar. 14
Spring Break -- No Classes


10
Mar. 18
Mar. 21

Modern human cultural and biological variation; “Race”; What can genes tell us?; Linguistic diversity; Ethnicity

Special Topic: Race? (Due March 25)


K: Chapter 8; P&B: Chapters 31 (Diamond—Race Without Color) & 33 (McIntosh)

11
Mar. 25




Mar. 28
Gender and sex
Film: Tough Guise--Violence, Media, and the Crisis in Masculinity




Food; Foodways and diet; Food taboos


Special Topic: Obesity—Should McDonald’s Be Held Responsible For Our Health? -or- Supersized!
(Due April 4)

K: Chapter 18 (We will not be covering this chapter in lecture or class discussion but you will be responsible for it on the exam)


P&B: Chapters 8 (Eaton & Konner), 29 (Cooper), & 35 (Lee)




12
Apr. 1


Apr. 4
“Modernization” and human health change; Obesity; Disease; Human plasticity

Exam 2 – Friday, April 4

P&B: 9 (Bogin) & 30 (Brown)(These readings ARE covered on Exam 2)

13
Apr. 8
Apr. 11
Contact; Colonialism; Political systems; Exchange; World systems

Film: First Contact


K: Chapters 21 & 22


14
Apr. 15





Apr. 18
Globalization; Technology; Cultural survival; Inequality

Special Topic: Technology—1-800-IDENTITY; Internet dating; Cell phone or pheromone? (Due April 22)


Human rights; Cultural relativism; Environmental rights / justice


K: Chapter 23; P&B: Chapter 55 (Bodley)




P&B: 52 (Kratz)

**Please note that I removed P&B Chapter 46 from the reading list to make your lives easier.  Also note that P&B chapter 52, which is assigned for this week, was incorrectly listed with Gruenbaum as the author (it is actually Kratz).
15
Apr. 22


Apr. 25

Applied anthropology--Forensic anthropology & human rights

Contemporary issues in anthropology; Applied anthropology
K: Chapter 24; P&B Chapter 37 (Murray)
16
May 2
Final Exam -- May 2, 11:20am-1:50pm

 
Reaction Paper Assignments

Reaction Paper #1--Due Tuesday, February 4
Special Topic: Biology & Behavior--T-Shirt Smelling College Students


Article: "Studies Explore Love and the Sweaty T-Shirt" by David Berreby (The New York Times, June 9, 1998)

Assignment Instructions:
Some questions you might consider:
These are only suggestions.  Please do not feel obligated to address all or even any of these questions.

Reaction Paper #2--Due Friday, February 28
Special Topic: Agriculture & Domestication--Mistakes that Keep on Giving?


Article: "The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race" by Jared Diamond (Chapter 11 of Podolefsky & Brown's Applying Anthropology).


Assignment Instructions:
Some questions you might consider:
Reaction Paper #3--Due Friday, March 25
Special Topic: Race?


Choose one of the following articles for your reaction paper:

"Race Without Color" by Jared Diamond (Chapter 31 of Podolefsky & Brown's Applying Anthropology).


"White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack" by Peggy McIntosh (Chapter 33 of Podolefsky & Brown's Applying Anthropology).

Assignment Instructions:
Reaction Paper #4--Due Friday, April 4
Special Topic: Obesity--Should McDonald's Be Held Responsible For Our Health? -or- Supersized!


Article: "The McNugget of Truth in the Fast-Food Lawsuits" by Adam Cohen (The New York Times, February 3, 2003)

Assignment Instructions:
Some questions you might consider:
Reaction Paper #5--Due Friday, April 22
Special Topic:
Technology—1-800-IDENTITY; Internet dating; Cell phone or pheromone?

Article: "Cell Phone or Pheromone? New Props for the Mating Game" by Natalie Angier (The New York Times, November 7, 2000)

Assignment Instructions:
Some questions you might consider:

Notes

January 17

Film: Franz Boas: The Shackles of Tradition

Questions:

1. How did Boas’ work among the Inuit (Eskimo) change the way we think about other cultures?

2. What was Boas’ academic background and how was this important in influencing his understanding of culture?

3. How did anti-Semitism shape Boas’ work?

4. Who was George Hunt and what role did he play in Boas’ fieldwork?

5. How was Boas influential in changing museum collections?

6. According to Boas, why was language central to understanding culture?

7. How was Boas important in preserving Kwakiutl traditions?

8. What was the source of the disagreement between Boas and Edward Curtis?

9. Why were Boas’ biological studies of immigrants important?

10. What was Boas’ view of race?

11. What did Boas mean by his question: “How can we recognize the shackles that tradition has laid upon us?”




January 24

Discussion Questions for January 24, 2003

1. Who are the Nacirema?

2. What are the “body rituals” that Miner discusses in his article on the Nacirema?

3. How did you react to the statement that the “fundamental belief underlying the whole [Nacirema] system appears to be that the human body is ugly and its natural tendency is to debility and disease” (p. 115)

4. What was your initial reaction to the Nacirema and their culture?

5. Why do you think that Miner wrote this article?

6. Why is the Nacirema article important for understanding the concepts of cultural relativism and ethnocentrism?

7. What suggestions does Miner’s presentation of the Nacirema give us for conducting fieldwork? What kinds of perspectives on a culture can an outsider have?

8. Think of another aspect of contemporary life (e.g., lifting weights at the gym) that can be looked at as a “body ritual” in the same way that Miner does in the Nacirema article.  Take a few minutes to think of an example. Describe this ritual to the other members of your group.  Were they able to immediately recognize it?

9. In Bohannan’s article “Shakespeare in the Bush,” what were the author’s original beliefs about the universality of the classics—such as Hamlet?  What is a classic?  What does this experience tell us about studying other cultures?

10. How did the Tiv elders react to the marriage of Hamlet’s mother to his uncle?  How was this different from Hamlet’s own reaction?

11. Why do the Tiv believe that a chief should have more than one wife?

12. What are some examples of American cultural traditions that might be difficult to translate?

13. In Kottak’s book, he makes the statement that culture is symbolic.  What does he mean by this?

14. We’ve talked about cultural relativism in this class and the need for respecting different cultural traditions.  Can you think of an example of when cultural traditions are challenged by the concept of universal human rights?  In these instances, how should this conflict be resolved?



January 31

Film: Among the Wild Chimpanzees

1. Why was the study of chimpanzees at Gombe initiated?  Why do you think that Louis Leakey thought it was important that Goodall was “untrained”?

2. How did Goodall gain acceptance into the chimpanzee community?  How did her presence alter the behavior of the chimpanzees she was studying?

3. Why was the discovery that chimpanzees made and used tools so important for studies of human evolution?

4. How are chimpanzee male dominance hierarchies established?

5. What did Goodall discover about meat eating and hunting in chimpanzees and why was this important?

6. What were the benefits of the long-term nature of the Gombe study?

7. What are some examples of learned behaviors that are seen in chimpanzees?

8. How do chimpanzees use non-verbal communication, such as touch, in their social relationships?

9. What are examples of aggressive behaviors in the Gombe chimpanzees?  What typically triggered these behaviors?




February 21

Discussion Questions for February 21, 2003

The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race, by Jared Diamond and
Disease and Death at Dr. Dickson’s Mounds by Alan H. Goodman and George J. Armelagos.

1. What is the progressivist view of history and what are the main points? What is the revisionist argument (Diamond’s) and what are the main points?

2. How has people’s health generally changed in the last 15,000 years?
 What evidence is given of how health has changed?

3. How has the development of agriculture affected equality generally and specifically gender equality?

4. What are the implications of what Diamond has pointed out? Should this affect the way that we subsist? Is his implied solution that we would be better off as hunters and gatherers?

5. What is life like generally for modern groups of hunters and gatherers like the Kalahari Bushmen?

6. Are the advantages of agriculture outweighed by the weaknesses addressed by Diamond?

7. Why did prehistoric peoples according to Goodman and Armelagos become farmers?

8. What happened to the population density around the mounds during the first fifty years of agriculture? What is the evidence cited by Goodman and Armelagos?

9. What are the results of agriculture according to Goodman and Armelagos?

10. What are the three factors that made this site (The Dickson Mounds) so useful to answering these questions?


March 4

Urbanism

Instructions:

Examine the city plans for Teotihuacan and Aleppo and consider the following questions.

1. What features of the city stand out?  What other features can be observed?

2. What does the layout of the city indicate about the organization of the city or society?

3. What can you tell about the developmental history of the city?  Do you think that it was planned or the result of a gradual conglomeration of different stages?  What do you think about the role of this city to the state?

4. How is this city similar or different to our class conception of the city, or to American cities in general?


March 7

Film: Mesopotamia: Return to Eden

1. What are the three main civilizations discussed in the film and in what time periods were they found?

2. All three of these are examples of state-level societies.  What are some of the main characteristics that we discussed in class that define state-level societies?

3. What was the significance of the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls?

4. What is the Code of Hammurabi and what is its significance?  What significance did writing have in general for state power?

5. Why were the findings in the Royal Tombs of Ur significant?  What are some of the ways that status can be assessed using archaeology?

6. How does the story of the Assyrian siege of Jerusalem demonstrate one of the problems with using historical records to interpret past events? 

7. How do the stories of Gilgamesh relate to those in the bible?

8. What is Dilmun?  Why do you think that stories about paradise are so common in different cultures?


March 21

Discussion Questions—Human Variation/Race

1. What does McIntosh mean by “an invisible package of unearned assets”?  How does she see this as related to the idea of meritocracy in the US?

2. Think about situations in which you were aware of your privilege or lack of privilege and how it influenced your behavior in those situations?

3. Can you add to McIntosh’s list of twenty-six situations that confer privilege?

4. When do issues of privilege seem most apparent?

5. How do McIntosh’s views on racial privilege apply to gender and class?

6. Is white privilege a serious threat to equality, or is merely an inconvenience?  What should be done to achieve the US ideal of social equality?

7. Did McIntosh’s article surprise you? Make you think differently about things?

8. According to Diamond, why is it acceptable to use the concept of race when talking about birds, but not humans?

9. Define race.  Why is race problematic for describing human biological variation?

10. What does Diamond mean when he talks about lack of concordance in human biological variation?

11. Where does the variation in human traits, such as those traits that have been used to classify races, come from in the first place?

12. What is a cline?  How can clines be helpful in describing and understanding human biological variation?

13. How does genetic variation figure into our discussion of race?  Does genetic variation provide us with an effective tool to classify humans?


March 25

Film: Tough Guise—Violence, Media, and the Crisis in Masculinity

1. What does Jackson Katz mean by the title of the film—Tough Guise?

2. When we assume that gender is only about women, what questions about men and masculinity remain invisible?

3. Why is the media’s portrayal of school shootings as “kids killing kids” problematic?

4. What does Katz say about the effects of widespread social and political movements (e.g., Civil Rights, Women’s Movement, Anti-War Movement, and Gay Liberation) on masculinity? 

5. What are the similarities and differences in the ways men of color and white men perform masculinity?

6. What solutions does Katz envision for addressing the crisis in masculinity?

April 11

Film: First Contact

1. When Australian gold prospectors first arrived who did the native inhabitants of highland New Guinea think that they were?

2. What was the reaction of the native people to the prospectors panning for gold in their rivers?

3. What were some of the unintended consequences of gold prospecting in highland New Guinea?

4. How did the native people and the prospectors deal with their fear and uncertainty about each other?

5. Were you surprised by the way that different people told stories of this first contact?  For example how native New Guinean women told of being sexually “sold” to the prospectors or the Leahy brothers talking about killing native people.

6. What, if anything, is owed to indigenous populations around the world by the European countries that colonized them beginning in the 16th century (and that continued through much of the 20th century)?

7. Anthropologists often find themselves in complex situations in fieldwork settings with regards to the people they study.  For example, think about Richard Lee in “Eating Christmas in the Kalahari”.  He refused to give the !Kung food as it would alter the results of his nutritional studies and he distributed tobacco in a way that annoyed the !Kung.  What do you think the role of the anthropologist should be in fieldwork (given this power differential) and what are their responsibilities to the people they study?


Lecture Notes

Lecture Notes for January 21 (Anthropological Fieldwork, Early Anthropologists, Studying Culture)

Lecture Notes for January 28 (Evolutionary Biology)

Lecture Notes for January 31 (Primates)

Lecture Notes for February 4 (Primates, Early Hominids)

Lecture Notes for February 11 (Later Hominids)

Lecture Notes for February 14 (Neandertals)

Lecture Notes for February 25 (Anatomically Modern Humans)

Lecture Notes for March 4 (Origins of the State; Urbanism)

Lecture Notes for March 7 (Urbanism; Writing)

Lecture Notes for March 18 (Human Biological Diversity; Race)

Lecture Notes for March 21 (Race; Human Diversity)

Lecture Notes for March 28 (Anthropology of Food)

Lecture Notes for April 1 (Anthropology of Food; Modernization; Obesity)

Lecture Notes for April 8 (Colonialism; Case Study: The Yakut)

Lecture Notes for April 15 (World Systems Theory)

Lecture Notes for April 18 (World Systems Theory; Cultural Relativism & Human Rights)

Lecture Notes for April 22 (Applied Anthropology [Forensic Anthropology & Human Rights])